Cluj München 1140km

Gânduri clujene din Bavaria

München - Munich - Monaco di Baviera

4. martie 2010 22:05
by skorpionking
7 Comentarii

Cica "In Romania, preturile locuintelor sunt corecte si fundamentate economic! O comparatie Bucuresti-München" ... sau cum induci oamenii in eroare daca nu ai date corecte

4. martie 2010 22:05 by skorpionking | 7 Comentarii

Cristian publica pe blogul sau un articol in care compara preturile la apartamentele din München si Bucuresti, salariile medii din aceste orase si implicit ce si in cat timp timp isi permit locuitorii respectivi in domeniul imobiliar. Analiza ar fi ok daca ar fi bazata pe date acurate, corecte. De la inceput am fost sceptic in ceea ce priveste datele prezentate. Citez:

"... Acum, sa vedem cum stau lucrurile in München, unul dintre orasele cu cel mai inalt standard de viata din lume si de asemenea, unul dintre cele mai scumpe orase din Germania.

In anul 2008, salariul mediu brut lunar anual al unui angajat german din sectorul industrial a fost de 41.500 de euro, insa tinand cont atat de faptul ca aceasta medie este trasa in jos de fostele landuri est-germane, cat si de faptul ca intr-un oras ca München salariile sunt peste medie, cel mai probabil un angajat münchenez castiga ~45.000 de euro pe an, ceea ce inseamna 3.750 euro brut pe luna sau 2400 euro net, respectiv de patru ori cat un bucurestean.

Prin urmare, normal ar fi ca in München preturile locuintelor sa fie de aproximativ 4 ori mai mari decat in Bucuresti, deci un apartament cu trei camere ar trebui sa coste intre 360 si 400.000 de euro.


Mai departe, atat bucuresteanul cat si münchenezul vor fi nevoiti sa imprumute bani de la banca pentru a isi cumpara locuinta respectiva. In Romania, un credit de 70.000 de euro pe 25 de ani presupune o rata lunara de aproximativ 480 de euro, ceea ce inseamna ca suma totala returnata bancii va fi de 144.000 de euro. Am luat in considerare un imprumut echivalent cu 75% din pretul locuintei.

In acelasi timp, un german va imprumuta 300.000 de euro pentru care va plati o rata lunara de aproximativ 1350 euro, adica 405.000 in 25 de ani. Cu alte cuvinte, o locuinta de 400.000 de euro il costa pe un german 505.000 cu tot cu dobanda la credit (210 venituri medii lunare), iar pe un roman o locuinta de 95.000 de euro il va costa 169.000 de euro (282 venituri medii lunare). Si astfel, diferenta dintre Bucuresti si München creste cu 40% doar din dobanda diferita aplicata de banci.

Una peste alta, comparativ cu proprietarii romani, cei germani ofera 1-2 camere in plus la aceeasi bani (multiplu de venit), bancile germane dau credite mult mai ieftine decat cele romanesti, iar autoritatile locale müncheneze ofera servicii publice mult mai bune decat cele din Bucuresti.


Cotidianul FAZ Frankfurter Allgemeiner Zeitung, unul de top 3 din Germania, spune intr-un articol (publicat astazi) ca salariul mediu brut in Germania e undeva la 27.000 EURO pe an. Diferenta fata de salariul mentionat de Cristian de 40.000 EURO pe an brut in München e de circa 50%, o diferenta imensa care e imposibila, diferenta reala fiind undeva la 10-15%. Deci calculele facute de Cristian nu sunt valabile si lumea a fost indusa in eroare. Din 27.000 EURO pe an brut raman ca. 17.000 EURO net anual, deci undeva la 1.500 net lunar. Ei bine, la banii astia, marit cu 15% la ca. 1800 EURO net lunar in München, refaceti calculele si vedeti cum ies :-) Nu care cumva sa credeti ca in Germania cateii umbla cu covrigi in coada si cu hable de bere in gura :-D Sigur, exista branse in Germania unde se castiga 50.000 EURO pe an brut, chiar 100.000 EURO pe an brut, in medie! Dar in general, salariul mediu brut anual in Germania e de 27.000 EURO! Cristian a fost prost informat, el s-a bazat doar pe datele care furnizeaza salariile medii anuale din industrie si servicii .. chiar daca Münchenul e dezvoltat, salariul mediu e cum a spus eu, nu la 40.000 EURO pe an brut... Sorry Cristian...

Bruttoverdienste sinken erstmals seit 1949

Textele din germana, inclusiv articolul complet din FAZ il puteti traduce folosind Traduce Instant.

Comentarii (7) -


media e de 27, corect
Munchen e cel mai scump, si valoarea de 40 nu pare deloc una ireala comparabila cu media Smile

cred ai vrut doar sa contrezi

un habarnist

Nu am vrut sa contrez, dar traiesc de 11 ani in acest oras si cunosc cum se traieste si stiu salariile, stiu despre ce vorbesc. Viata e grea si aici. Daca castiga fiecare, sotul si sotia, fiecare 50 k EURO/an, atunci merge treaba, sau macar impreuna 80 k EURO/an, altfel e f greu cu un apartament aici...multa lume se teme ca ramana fara atunci tre sa se mute in alt loc si ce fac daca au credit imens in carca?!

foloren torium

When I originally commented I clicked the -Notify me when new comments are added- checkbox and now each time a comment is added I get four emails with the same comment. Is there any way you can remove me from that service? Thanks!

Marnie Bargeron

Posts are great! Thanks for the author

Tiara Kautzman

<b>A free adult sex cam chat with (nearly) no limits!Thousands of free webcams from all over the world are waiting for you. Most of the performers are from America, but you also find others. At this free adult sex cam chat everything is free until a certain point. That means you will see couples fucking, solo girls playing with their beautiful bodies, gay people playing with each other and even transsexuals pleasuring themselves or their partner.Large thumbnails instead of weird signups or whatever are on the index pages no other cam sites, so you get direct access without any extra clicks. And yes, all their thumbs are real and live. So if you like one, just click it and you will see exactly what happened on the thumb a few seconds ago.You can choose your favorite cams by Featured, Female, Male, Couples, Transgender, and Groups if you are looking for something special. There is an enormous amount of different webcams online 24x7 with all kind of people.You can visit the site and have great time with open mind peoples :</b>;

Branden Gisriel

<b>DOWNLOAD FOR FREE ---> Bohemian Rhapsody (2018). The story of the legendary rock band Queen and lead singer Freddie Mercury, leading up to their famous performance at Live Aid (1985).<a href="">Click Here to download the movie !!!</a></b>

Inger Berns

<b>Create Energy When Talking On Your Phone. More and more people are afraid that they will have to give up some of the household appliances they have so much longed for because the energy consumption is far above their financial possibilities.Thus, after months or even years of saving money in order to purchase what they want and like the most, many individuals see the need of getting rid of them because they no longer can afford paying huge electricity bills.Most of the times giving up those electrical appliances also means giving up comfort and turning back to a lifestyle characteristic to the past years, it means frustration and sorrow and sometimes even hours wasted by doing by hand something which an electrical appliance can do in a few minutes.If your electricity bill is sucking out your last pennies, then you probably know what I am talking about.However, this situation which for many people seems hopeless can be solved in a much easier and comfortable way.All you need in order to diminish your energy bill is another source of energy, a cheap and easy to use source that will provide you with enough energy to power small appliances and significantly lower the amount of power you use from the national or local electricity provider.This power source, which can represent your salvation, is the banal phone line.Each and every day, power runs through the phone cables, power which is mainly used for keeping the phone working and sustaining the conversation.During the day, this power is used, as people are talking on the phone, but during the late hours of the night the number of people using the phone line is relatively low, so that you can gather all that energy and use it to power your appliances.This energy is included in your phone bill, so there is something you pay for, thus you have all the right to use something for which you pay.To fully take advantage of this type of power you will need a device which will gather the energy from the phone and make it ready for use.The good thing about this device is that, even though it is more efficient during the night, it can also be used during the day or even when you are speaking on the phone.You will see that in a few months you will be able to use all your appliances and still save money on your electricity bill to fulfill some of your dreams. You can read more information here : </b>

Adaugă comentariu